June 15, 2003

No US Troops, Mr. Friedman

Because if the two sides cannot emerge from this dead end, then you can forget about a two-state solution, which is what both Hamas's followers and the extremist Jewish settlers want. They each want a one-state solution, in which their side will control all of Israel, the West Bank and Gaza. The one-state solution would mean the end of the Zionist enterprise, because Israel can rule such an entity, in which there would soon be more Arabs than Jews, only by apartheid or ethnic cleansing. It would also mean the end of Palestinian nationalism, because the Israelis will crush the Palestinians rather than be evicted. That is the outcome we are heading toward, though, unless the only reality principle left, the United States of America, really intervenes — with its influence, its wisdom and, if necessary, its troops.

Thomas Friedman has it mostly right, but we must not send US troops to Israel while helping to solve this intractable problem. I very much doubt that we will see the Palestinians and the Israelis at peace in my lifetime, if ever. In the end this conflict is a spiritual problem not amenable to a political solution.

No comments: